top of page

Etsy or Your Own Website: Navigating the Digital Storefront Dilemma

Hey there, savvy business owners! Today, we're tackling a question as old as the internet (okay, not that old, but still): Should your small business sell on Etsy, host its own website, or juggle both? Strap in as we explore this digital storefront conundrum with a dash of wit and a whole lot of practical advice.

Etsy: The Artisan's Digital Marketplace

Etsy is like that bustling farmers' market but in the digital world – a place where unique, handmade, and vintage items feel right at home. Here's why you might want to set up shop on Etsy:

  1. Built-In Traffic: Etsy's like a magnet for customers looking for something special. It's like showing up at a party where everyone's already interested in what you've got.

  2. Community and Credibility: Etsy's known for its supportive community and credibility among customers who love supporting small businesses and artisans.

  3. Ease of Use: Setting up on Etsy is as easy as pie – a really, really simple pie.

But Wait, There's a Catch!

Before you jump on the Etsy bandwagon, consider this:

  • Fees, Fees, Fees: Etsy charges listing fees, transaction fees, and payment processing fees. These can add up faster than you can say "cha-ching!"

  • Less Control: Your shop, your rules? Not so much on Etsy. You're playing in someone else's sandbox, which means less control over branding and customer experience.

Your Website: The Kingdom You Rule

Having your own website is like owning a piece of digital real estate. It's all yours, and here's why that's awesome:

  1. Brand Identity Stronghold: Your website is a blank canvas for your brand. Paint it with your colors, style, and voice.

  2. More Control: From pricing to customer data – you're the boss, applesauce!

  3. Direct Customer Relationships: Build a direct line to your customers without a middleman. It's just you and them, getting to know each other.

The Flip Side of Website Royalty

However, with great power comes great responsibility:

  • You Need Traffic: Unlike Etsy, you've got to bring your own crowd. This means investing in SEO, marketing, and social media to drive traffic.

  • Maintenance and Upkeep: Websites don't run themselves (yet). You'll need to play tech support or hire someone who can.

Why Not Both?

Here's a wild idea: Why not use both Etsy and your website? Etsy for exposure and community, your website for brand control and direct customer relationships. It's like having your cake and eating it too, but with more sales and less sugar.

Final Thoughts: A Roadmap for Digital Success

So, here's my sage advice: When you're just starting out, set up shop on Etsy. It's like having training wheels for your online business – giving you access to a built-in audience, community support, and a hassle-free start. As your brand grows and you start to see engagement, followers, and those exciting sales, it's time to expand your empire. That's when you should also establish your own website. Think of it as graduating from a bustling marketplace to your own flagship store. Doing both? It's not just savvy, it's strategic – leveraging Etsy for its audience and your website for brand autonomy. This dual approach can be the sweet spot for small businesses looking to make a big impact in the digital world.

Remember, in the realm of online sales, flexibility and adaptation are your best friends. Whether it's on Etsy, your website, or both, your unique brand story and quality products are your ace in the hole. Ready to conquer the digital marketplace? Go forth young grasshopper!



30 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All


bottom of page